Starry Night Gifting Quest Walkthrough & Rewards

Before you start

Steps marked “one of” have alternative entries: which one you get depends on your choices.

I'm in charge of choosing a good gift for Theo for the Starry Night Festival! There's a toymaker in the market who has toys available. I should check with Theo's friends about what he likes.
This entry is added automatically when the story moves on.
I've got a gift for Theo. I hope he likes it!
This entry is added automatically when the story moves on.
One of 3
Theo loved his marbles! What a success!
Completion
Talk to Theo at Starry Night Celebration.
Answer +[Give Marbles]
You'll need
Marbles
Hand over
Marbles
Rewards
Theo's Hat GiftSteam achievement
Show dialogue (2 lines)
You
+[Give Marbles]
Theo
Yes! New marbles!! This is the best Starry Night ever! Thank you so much! I’ve got something for you too. I made it myself!
or
Theo seemed happy enough with his gift!
Completion
Talk to Theo at Starry Night Celebration.
Answer +[Give Cards]
You'll need
SwordPaint SetDollCards
Hand over
Paint SetDollCardsSword
Show dialogue (2 lines)
You
+[Give Cards]
Theo
Oh… Thank you!
or
I didn't manage to get anything for Theo.
Completion
Talk to Theo at Starry Night Celebration.
Answer I'm sorry I didn't get you anything.
Show dialogue (2 lines)
You
I'm sorry I didn't get you anything.
Theo
Oh… that’s okay.

Spoilers: the answers you can pick and where they lead.

Choices

+[Give Cards]needs Cardsleads to step 3Hand over: Cards
+[Give Doll]needs Dollleads to step 3Hand over: Doll
+[Give Marbles]needs Marblesleads to step 3Hand over: MarblesRewards: Theo's Hat GiftRewards: Steam achievement
+[Give Paint Set]leads to step 3Hand over: Paint Set
+[Give Sword]needs Swordleads to step 3Hand over: Sword
I'm sorry I didn't get you anything.leads to step 3

Some rewards depend on the branch you take.